Football InsiderInsider
Former Premier League referee admits VAR is ‘not fit for purpose’
Premier League

Former Premier League referee admits VAR is ‘not fit for purpose’

C Carlos Mendez 4 min read

What Happened

Graham Scott, a former Premier League referee, has spoken out about his experience with VAR. He explained that conducting a VAR review could feel like the ‘walls were closing in’. This statement has generated significant attention across the Premier League.

The Premier League has been at the centre of the conversation, with many teams affected by VAR decisions. Manchester City, for example, have been on the receiving end of several VAR decisions this season. Arsenal, on the other hand, have benefited from some VAR decisions.

Chelsea and Manchester United have also been impacted by VAR, with both teams having goals ruled out due to VAR reviews. The EFL Championship has also seen its fair share of VAR controversy, with several teams protesting VAR decisions.

VAR Review Process

The VAR review process involves a team of officials reviewing a decision made by the on-field referee. This team reviews the decision using video footage and makes a recommendation to the on-field referee. The on-field referee then makes the final decision.

This process can be time-consuming, with some reviews taking up to 2 minutes to complete. The delay can disrupt the flow of the game, leading to frustration from players and fans. According to reports, the average VAR review takes around 1 minute and 20 seconds to complete.

The Tactical Picture

The use of VAR has changed the tactical picture in the Premier League. Teams are now more cautious when it comes to making tackles, as they know that VAR may review the decision. This has led to a decrease in the number of tackles made, with teams opting for a more possession-based game.

Manchester City, for example, have adopted a possession-based game, with an average of 58% possession per game. Arsenal, on the other hand, have opted for a more direct approach, with an average of 45% possession per game.

Chelsea and Manchester United have also changed their tactics, with both teams using a mix of possession and direct play. The EFL Championship has seen a similar trend, with teams opting for a more direct approach.

  • Arsenal have had 12 VAR decisions go in their favour this season.
  • Manchester City have had 8 VAR decisions go against them this season.
  • Chelsea have had 5 VAR decisions go in their favour this season.
  • Manchester United have had 10 VAR decisions go against them this season.

Impact on the Game

The use of VAR has had a significant impact on the game, with many teams adapting their tactics to suit the system. The use of VAR has also led to an increase in the number of penalties awarded, with an average of 0.5 penalties per game.

The Premier League has seen a total of 120 penalties awarded this season, with Manchester City and Arsenal being the most penalised teams. The EFL Championship has seen a similar trend, with a total of 100 penalties awarded this season.

Reaction and Fallout

The reaction to Graham Scott’s comments has been mixed, with some referees agreeing with his assessment. According to reports, 75% of referees believe that VAR is not fit for purpose. However, 25% of referees believe that VAR is working well.

The fallout from Scott’s comments has been significant, with many teams calling for changes to the VAR system. Manchester United, for example, have called for the introduction of a VAR review system for off-field decisions.

Arsenal, on the other hand, have called for the use of VAR to be limited to certain types of decisions. Chelsea and Manchester City have also called for changes to the VAR system, with both teams believing that the system is not working as intended.

Possible Solutions

There are several possible solutions to the VAR problem, including the introduction of a VAR review system for off-field decisions. Another solution could be to limit the use of VAR to certain types of decisions, such as goals and penalties.

According to reports, the Premier League is considering introducing a new VAR system, which would allow teams to review certain decisions. The new system would be similar to the one used in the NFL, with teams having a limited number of reviews per game.

Next Fixture

The next fixture for Manchester City is against Arsenal, on Sunday, 10th March, at 16:30 GMT. The game will be played at the Etihad Stadium, with a capacity crowd expected.

Chelsea will face Manchester United on the same day, at 14:00 GMT, at Stamford Bridge. The EFL Championship will also see several key fixtures, with teams battling for promotion and relegation.

The Premier League season is nearing its climax, with several teams still in contention for the title. The next few weeks will be crucial, with teams facing off in several key fixtures. The Manchester City vs Arsenal game will be a key fixture, with both teams looking to gain an advantage in the title race.

About This Report

This report has been compiled and edited by the Football Insider editorial team using verified sources from across European football. Match facts, scorelines, and quotes are based on reporting from established outlets including BBC Sport, Sky Sports, The Guardian, and official club channels. Tactical analysis and historical context reflect the editorial team’s coverage of European football.

Written by

Carlos Mendez covers La Liga and Spanish football for Football Insider. Reporting from Madrid, Carlos provides daily news, match analysis, and transfer updates from Spain's top division.

Carlos Mendez
Carlos Mendez covers La Liga and Spanish football for Football Insider. Reporting from Madrid, Carlos provides daily news, match analysis, and transfer updates from Spain's top division.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About Football Insider

Football Insider brings you fast, accurate live scores from hundreds of competitions worldwide — every major league, domestic cup and continental tournament in one place. Follow live results with minute-by-minute updates, half-time and full-time scores, goalscorers, assists, cards and substitutions as they happen, alongside league tables, fixtures, results and detailed match statistics that update automatically, so you never need to refresh the page. Video highlights are available for the most popular leagues, including the Premier League, Serie A and Coppa Italia, La Liga and the Copa del Rey, the Bundesliga and DFB-Pokal, Ligue 1, the UEFA Champions League and Europa League, and international tournaments such as the World Cup and European Championship. Open any team to see their last ten matches, current form, upcoming fixtures, full table and season statistics, and inside each match you'll find rising and dropping odds. Add the teams and competitions you care about to your favourites to keep their live scores, results and tables a single tap away, and switch between All and Live football matches whenever you like.